Knife-point robbery spree accused refused bail despite telling judge: 'I'm a good person'

Courts Reporting Scheme
Tallaght Courthouse

A man accused of carrying out a spree of knife-point shop robberies in south Dublin has been refused bail, despite telling a judge: “I’m a good person.”

Eoin Fleming (43), of Elmcastle Drive, Tallaght, Dublin 24, appeared before Judge Edward Carroll at Tallaght District Court charged with three counts of robbery over a five-day period.

Garda Patrick Browne told the court that the alleged robberies took place on September 11, 14 and 15.

Mr Fleming is accused of robbing Daybreak on Greenhills Road of €280, Centra at Castletymon Shopping Centre of €685 and Spar at Old Court Shopping Centre in Firhouse of €390. All three charges are contrary to Section 14 of the Criminal Justice (Theft and Fraud Offences) Act 2001.

The court heard that during the most recent alleged robbery, at Spar on September 15, a man wearing a black balaclava and black Nike runners entered the shop armed with what Garda Browne described as a “very large” carving knife with a metal handle. The suspect fled with the scene with €390.

A short time later, a man was seen in the Kilkee Park area removing and discarding black clothing before he was spotted wearing grey trousers and a red Barcelona football jersey.

Following arrests, gardaí recovered a large silver kitchen knife from the back of a car, along with a black balaclava.

The €390 allegedly taken from Spar was also recovered.

Garda Browne said officers subsequently linked Mr Fleming to the two earlier robberies through CCTV footage and similarities in the clothing, footwear, knife and the suspect’s gait.

In the September 14 incident at Centra in Castletymon Shopping Centre, a man allegedly brandished a large kitchen knife before €685 was handed over.

That money has not been recovered, the court heard.

Mr Fleming is also accused of robbing Daybreak on Greenhills Road on September 11.

The court heard that a man allegedly grabbed a shop worker by the arm while armed with a large knife, before taking approximately €280 from the till which was also not recovered.

Garda Browne said the “modus operandi”in the three alleged robberies was “identical”.

He referred to similarities in the clothing, including an Armani top with distinctive branding down the sleeves, as well as the Nike runners and the knife allegedly used.

However, the court heard that CCTV from the earlier robberies did not visually identify Mr Fleming as the man involved.

As Mr Fleming was not legally represented, Judge Carroll questioned Garda Browne about the evidence allegedly linking him to the earlier offences.

The judge noted that black Nike runners were not uncommon and clarified that gardaí were relying on a combination of the suspect’s clothing, footwear, gait and the similarity of the knife.

Gardaí strongly objected to bail under the O’Callaghan rules and Section 2 of the Bail Act. Garda Browne also raised concerns that Mr Fleming could commit further serious offences if released.

Addressing Mr Fleming himself, Judge Carroll asked why he should not be granted bail.

“I’m a good person”, he told the court. He said he had a family, including three young children and a partner, as well as a job.

Judge Carroll asked whether Mr Fleming wished to call anyone to give evidence in support of his bail application.

Mr Fleming declined.

Judge Carroll refused bail, saying he had considered the objections under both the O’Callaghan rules and Section 2 of the Bail Act, but found the Section 2 objection more compelling.

He referred to the serious nature of the charges, the sentences that could be imposed in the event of conviction and the garda apprehension that Mr Fleming could commit further serious offences if released.

Mr Fleming was remanded in custody to appear before the court again on September 24.

Funded by the Courts Reporting Scheme