A 68-year-old man, who is accused of raping a woman during a violent burglary in south Dublin more than 23 years ago, has been refused bail after a judge found the risk of him potentially committing similar serious offences was too high.
The man, who cannot be named for legal reasons, appeared before Judge Anne Watkin at Dún Laoghaire District Court charged with two counts of rape, one count of false imprisonment and one count of aggravated burglary while allegedly carrying a knife.
All four charges arise from the same alleged incident involving a woman who was in her 30s at the time, at her home in a residential estate in south Dublin on March 31, 2003.
Detective Inspector Trevor Scanlon, of Dundrum Garda Station, objected to bail under both the O’Callaghan rules and section 2 of the Bail Act.
Det Insp Scanlon said gardaí alleged the incident had been recorded by the accused and were attempting to obtain footage. He said the accused had denied knowing the woman when questioned. The court heard that the woman suffered bruising to her wrists and Det Insp Scanlon described the alleged incident as involving a “horrific assault” in addition to rape.
He also raised concerns about images and videos allegedly connected to the accused depicting home break-ins, rape and murder. He said some of the content showed a woman being raped and murdered in her own home after a man broke in.
“That worries me”, he told the court.
Det Insp Scanlon also told the court there was strong DNA evidence and witnesses who allegedly placed the accused at the door of the woman’s home.
Judge Watkin questioned why it had taken more than 23 years for gardaí to identify and arrest the accused. Det Insp Scanlon said gardaí had developed criminal intelligence but declined to expand on this further.
Under the O’Callaghan rules, he also objected to bail on the basis that the accused had “no ties to the jurisdiction” and might abscond.
Judge Watkin rejected this, noting that although the accused had no job or family ties in the area, he was a mortgage-free home owner and would stand to lose a substantial amount of money if he fled.
She described the case as “very unusual” and said it was far from “open and shut”, adding that the trial could ultimately come down to an issue of consent.
Judge Watkin noted that “it’s her words against his” and said bruising could occur during consensual sex, while the material referred to by gardaí could potentially reflect an interest in rough sex rather than rape.
She added that consent would ultimately be a matter for trial.
Defence solicitor, Andrew Vallely, argued that his client had lived in the community for 23 years and that strict conditions could address the court’s concerns.
He said the accused was willing to sign on at a garda station twice daily, remain at his home address and stay in contact with gardaí by phone.
Mr Vallely said his client was being “totally pragmatic and realistic” and urged the court to consider whether such conditions could provide a sufficient “buffer” against any perceived risk.
He also argued that the accused was entitled to have different “pastimes” and that the material referred to by gardaí did not establish that he would commit an offence if released.
Returning her decision, Judge Watkin said the application involved balancing the presumption of innocence against the seriousness of the alleged offences and the risk and potential consequences of further offending.
She described the allegations as among the most serious a court could consider “short of murder”.
Judge Watkin also referred to the videos and images allegedly connected to the accused man, saying that 23 years after the alleged offence he remained “invested in this type of thing”.
Describing it as “one of the most difficult bail applications I’ve ever had to do”, Judge Watkin said: “I believe that this charge was so significant and so serious… someone could have died”.
She added: “I believe there is a risk of reoffending and the risk is too high to grant bail on any conditions, and the potential consequences of reoffending are too serious.”
Judge Watkin refused bail under section 2 of the Bail Act and adjourned the case to Cloverhill District Court on November 10. Mr Vallely also applied for legal aid.
